A student emailed me last week (hey, Vicki!) with a problem I think most painters face.
She was stuck in that difficult space between wanting to paint and overthinking every decision about what to actually paint.
That uncertainty can easily stop your enthusiasm to get back to the easel.
To break the cycle, she decided on a simple idea…
Return to the same object and paint it in different colour ways, using the blue coffee jug from the Still Life E-book as a familiar starting point.
This is actually a brilliant way to learn.
When you remove the anxiety of constantly searching for new subjects, your attention can move onto the real foundations of painting.
If you’re in a similar situation, here are some colour palettes you can use to develop your painting skills without constantly having to find a new subject to paint.
A simple object becomes familiar territory
When you’re painting the same jug over and over again, you can practise ellipses and shadow mapping. You begin to instinctively understand the proportions of the object. Your hand becomes steadier because you are solving the same visual problems repeatedly rather than looking for new ones every session.
Then the colour schemes themselves become the lesson.
Burnt Umber + White
Warm and very traditional, this is an excellent palette for learning form and understanding value relationships.
Similar to the first shadow-mapping exercise in the e-book, adding white to the Burnt Umber gives you a full range of tonal values to work with.
Earth colours have long been used for oil painting underpaintings because they tend to dry relatively quickly compared with many other pigments. That makes this simple monochrome setup an ideal palette for practice studies.
You could also use Winsor & Newton Galeria Pale Umber, which is a mixture of Burnt Umber and White, as a ground colour. Combined with the monochrome palette, it creates a really strong traditional starting point to experiment with.
Pale Umber, in the student Galeria Range
Raw Umber + White
Softer and slightly cooler.
Great for subtle value shifts, especially with yellows. If you think of Raw Umber as a dark yellow, it can be a very effective colour for darkening yellows without causing colour drift. On the ‘How to paint light and shade‘ tutorial, you can see how effective Raw Umber can be as a colour neutraliser. In this tutorial, I use Cadmium Yellow Light, muted with Raw Umber, for the apple’s form.
Ultramarine Blue + White


Thank you, Will! Your articles are always so educational! I’ve learned most of my color theory and painting techniques from you! Even your articles on your musuem trips have expanded my knowledge of art and art history! Though there’s still a lot to learn, I’ve become a more skilled painter and confident artist because you are able to break down the lessons into manageable, easy to follow chunks. Appreciate you!!
You are a blessing!
Chacha
Thanks so much Chacha, that’s very kind of you to say so, so pleased you’ve been enjoying the teachings.
Will
Thank you, Will! Your posts are so inspiring. The level of detail that is so “on point” has excited beginners over again, to try the methods you describe. Thank you for sharing your knowledge as beginners try to tackle color and value. It is very helpful!
So pleased that you’re feeling inspired Lynn, I really hope you find it helpful when building palettes for your paintings.
Will
I completely agree with Chacha and could not have put it better. I’m always investigating other artists who teach but no non-measure up to your excellence, Will.
Hey Kathleen, That’s very kind of you to say. So glad you enjoy them.
Will
As I read I became lost , not at my easel at all , not at my paper and graphite
I’m thinking on the pallet, I have no violet iron oxide no venetian red , yet I still have a very strong urge to make those colours and do this study , I remember reading this tutorial when you 1st added to your posts , it looked impressive to me and yet simplistic enough for a try,…. The value in repeating and excluding is key , what a fab read , thanks so much for you endless talent and sharing always speaks to me
Hey Kim, It can be a great exercise to see how you can mix those pigments you haven’t got from the ones you’ve already got. For the violet iron oxide, you’re trying to get a muted purple, so you could use an ultramarine blue and a crimson or a bit of cad red that would work. And for the Venetian red again try mixing a richer red, so if you’ve got a cadmium red and then add in some burnt umber into it to mute it down.
Will
Will , it is like you knew I only had those to mix from(old faithful pallet )
thank you for formulae’s ,they shall be perfect now …
This is an excellent article. Thank you for sharing this. I hope I can be disciplined with my time to do all of the exercises!
Thanks very much Karen
Thanks Will – one of your best emails – lots of excellent points – have printed it out to keep! Bonnie
So pleased you enjoyed it Bonnie.
Will
Thank you, Will! So concisely informative and helpful.
Cheers John, hope you’re keeping well.
Will
Oh Will your articles are always so timely and informative! I’ve been really trying to compress my values lately and working with limited palettes. Basically trying to make my paintings look a bit more sophisticated! My favourite oil combo is Gamblin Transparent orange and phthalo blue – it makes a stunning range of muted greens. Honestly, your tuition is next level and so generous. I recommend you to anyone new to painting.
Thanks so much Debbie, and that sounds like a great pairing, phthalo blue can be so nice.
Will
Hi Will,
I really like your articles on colour mixing. I find that it involves both hemispheres of my brain. Your critical analysis combined with your ability to bring a subject to life on a two dimensional canvas are unparalleled. I also like the museum visits. Art history is one of my favourite subjects, and I look forward to posts on that subject.
Cheers.
Thanks so much Sonja, that’s lovely to hear.
Will
I’m so glad to come across this article, Will. I was just recently feeling unmotivated on painting, but this is quite inspiring. Would this be something that I could apply to landscape painting?
Hey Laura, yes it would work really well for landscapes. What would be handy is to stick with the ones that are a bit cooler or more towards green, so the raw umber and white, and then the yellow ochre, ivory black, and titanium white. They’ll be good basics for landscapes to establish a muted colour structure.
Will
Hi Will,
My first time posting since following you and joining your newsletter. I have just finished my third read of this article. It’s great- an excellent breakdown. I’m going to give the Jug a shot.
Thank you.
Elizabeth
Hey Elizabeth, great to have you along and really pleased you enjoyed it. The jug is a great demo to practice these techniques. Really hope you enjoy it.
Cheers,
Will
Hi Will – thanks so much for sharing your knowledge and inspirational articles.
Love your work.
Teresa
Cheers Teresa, pleased you enjoyed it.
Will
Will, always when I think…O I can’t do it….you open up the door…yet again..and it all becomes possible…I enjoy your lessons and informative posts so much…thanks for providing a creative springboard into summer painting…
Cheers
Lawrence
Thanks Lawrence, so pleased it helped.
Will